Skip to main content

A Matter of Perspective - Home Fire

"Home Fire" intrinsically challenges the reader to reevaluate their base interpretation of the book's main themes, e.g. betrayal, belonging, identity, motivation, and sacrifice. Shamsie is able to most successfully fulfill this through each section of the book coming from a different character's perspective. For example, through Isma's section, Parvaiz is painted as a deserter, one who abandoned his family for selfish reasons. While partially true, analysis of the entire context—i.e. understanding Parvaiz's perspective—shows a vastly more complex situation. Yes, Parvaiz abandoned the family, but not out of cynicism—rather because he saw a near future where Isma and Aneeka would leave him. His actions were a reaction to his situation. That is a deeper understanding of the situation that is only made possible through a section of the book being written from a different character's perspective.

Shamsie likely chose Isma to begin the book because she offers the most outside and baseline perspective on the situation. Both literally in that she is in connecting to the other characters from America, and she is more personally distant as she doesn't have as deep a connection as the twins or intimate as Aneeka and Eamonn have. Isma very successfully sets up the story for the reader while introducing Eamonn. Eamonn is then able to connect Isma's story to the rest—connecting America to Britain. Eamonn and Aneeka's relationship ends with continuity into Parvaiz's current situation. Overall, the choice of order leads the reader onto a rollercoaster of conflicting perspectives and what is actually happening vs. what is a failure of perspective. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Antigone vs. Home Fire

What stood out to me at the beginning of Antigone was the parallel fight between Ismene vs. Antigone and Isma vs. Aneeka. Ismene—like Isma—took the logical stance of conservative protection, opting to sacrifice a proper burial of her already dead brother for the safety of the two living sisters. Both Ismene and Isma sacrifice a level of their integrity for the larger picture, knowing they would like to fulfill their religious obligation to bury their brother as they are supposed to. But at the same time, knowing that adherence to their beliefs would be detrimental to their lives. They both choose to look towards the future and what their—and Antigone/Aneeka's—lives could hold if they do the socially expected outcome of not properly burying their brother. They choose to avoid conflict in the name of safety.  Whereas both Antigone and Aneeks cannot continue their lives if they sacrifice their integrity to abide by social pressures. Both of their lives are so dependent on faith and fa...

Gender in Pachinko

 The female characters' intellect is more subtle and transactions: for example, bargaining at the pawnshop and market. Society does not allow women to express and pursue their education and intellect explicitly, but Lee does a good job of making it clear that—even though society disagrees—these women are incredibly intelligent and capable. Nonetheless, they are still disadvantaged by society because of their gender—Sunja gets pregnant out of wedlock and is pressured to leave her home and family in Korea in order to 1) marry someone, so she doesn't get judged, and 2) have someone to provide for her. A lot of the social pressures she faces are based on the gender expectations society has for her. She is not supposed to be/encouraged to be smart or to pursue an education, instead her social expectations are that of a mother. In contrast, men are revered for their intellect, wealth, and power. Hansu is rich and powerful, so we see him attempt to use his influence to control those a...

Final Project Update

My research for my final project has not really officially started, although I have started doing some brainstorming on potential topics that I would like to write about. At mid-quarter, it can be challenging to envision the final project, especially when have only been in class for a short time because of the quarter system. Also, we still have a book and a half to read, which will influence my research and help me develop new ideas. And seeing how other people start/plan to start their projects will help me navigate my own.  As for questions or struggles, at this stage, I am mostly worried about figuring out the focus or direction of my project. I have not yet chosen a platform to use, however, depending on the specific topic I choose, I really liked the interface of StoryMap. I think it portrayed the text and map better than Neatline. If I have a final topic that uses geography, I will definitely consider using StoryMap. Overall, I feel a little overwhelmed and unsure at this st...